Cause of textile waste and its control in the spinning mills
by
Muhammad Mushtaq Ahmad, MTS, Lahore.
Each drafting operation introduces fresh irregularity, the
irregularity of the final yarn is summation of irregularities
produced during each operation. Roll drafting or the attenuation
of slivers and rovings to produce yarn of specific count is the
most important principle involved in the processing of raw
material into yarn. The irregularity introduced in drafting
process mainly depends upon the parameters of the drafting
system, mechanical faults and quality of the input material.
When mechanical faults are eliminated, drafting
irregularities depend upon to control on the floating fibers in
the drafting zone. Setting between the roller nips, distance
between the apron at the nip, distance between the apron at the
nip, and pressure on the top rollers are some of the factors.
The characteristics of the sliver fed to the drafting system
also exercise considerable influence on the irregularities
introduced and drafting system, operated under the optimum
conditions. Short fiber content, neps, trash and other
impurities, in addition to the degree of fiber parallelization
and number and extend of residual hooks in the fibers together
with their direction of presentation are some of the important
factors that characterize sliver quality and determine its
behavior during drafting.
Nutter and Slater examined the effect of hooked
fibers on yarn strength and found that better strength is
obtained when a fiber tip is presented to the drafting system
than a hooked end. Grade, Wakanker and Bhaduri
found better yarn regularity and strength, when majority hooks
are fed as trailing, as leading to the ring frame.
They further found that the yarn quality diminishes with
increase in the number of majority hooks, when these are fed as
leading. Simpson, Deluca and Flori also confirmed
that feeding majority hooks as leading to the ring frame
contributed to poorer yarn quality and more breakages, the
effect being pronounced in case of fine yarns. Apart from hooks,
the fiber parallelization may also effect on drafting
irregularities.
The treatment given to raw material during spinning process
through various machines greatly influences not only the quality
of spun yarn but also its quantum. Factors like setting between
rollers, draft distribution, Pressure on top rollers, shore
hardness of rubber cots, spacers, type/size of ring travelers,
rings, relative humidity in the plant and mixing of raw material
etc, contribute towards the quality and quantity of yarn.
Moisture content in the raw material especially in cotton is
very important because of its direct effect on yarn strength as
well as elongation and neps in the yarn. Whereas, the strength
and elongation directly affect the performance of yarn in
warping, the neps influence surface of finished cloth and dye
take up.
Discussion
If a given mixing is not handled properly, some of the fibers
may be damaged during its passage through various machines. As a
result the waste percentage would increase and the quality of
yarn would deteriorate. Moreover, the yarn manufactured under
such conditions would result in reduced profit margin due to
increased costs.
Conversion of lap into yarn is a question of reducing weight
per unit length of the input material, and, at the same time,
maintaining product uniformity. The uniformity is achieved by
appropriate rate of draft; higher drafts above certain optimum
limits produce irregularity with the advent of high drafting,
much more attention has to be paid to accurate setting for
maintaining quality. In practice, the reduction in weight per
unit length is carried out in stages; each drafting operation
introduces fresh irregularity; the irregularity of final yarn
being the summation of irregularities produced at each
operation.
Fiber breakage is a very important factor, because any
increase in breakage can lead to additional fly waste and
greater number of ends down. Fiber breakage is a function of two
main factors; the ratch setting setting (the distance between
consecutive roll pairs in a roller drawing system) and the
roving twist. To avoid breakages, it is necessary to set the
ratch longer than the longest fiber, because a shorter ratch
will break all fibers greater in length.
For a given ratch the extent of machine control over the
fiber depend on the length distribution; a wider distribution
and a longer ratch lead to lesser fiber control. The strain and
distortion imposed on fiber ends during drafting due to the
initial pull, continually repeated at each operation also lead
to an increase in breakages. It is to be expected, therefore,
that fiber will be beheaded or betailed as a result of this
stress and fatigue, the effect being more pronounced in case of
longer fibers.
Blending of different varieties of cotton is usually the
responsibility of the spinner. With natural fibers, like cotton
maintenance of a completely uniform blend can be very difficult.
A spinner’s first concern is to control staple length and
fiber fineness so as to maintain consistent conditions and
standard yarn properties. His second concern is with yarn’s
appearance. Generally speaking a spinner has to sure, that if
yarns out of different dispatches (lots) from the factory are
compared, the weaver/ user should not be able to see any
difference between different lots).
For achieving uniform blend, good quality, higher production,
sandwich/ Stack mixing, block creeling and cross creeling/ color
coding at each operation is must.
Yarn breakages and their gradual increases with higher
spindle speed poses another bit problem. Frequent yarn breakages
result in higher waste percentage and the quality of yarn is
also impaired due to thick places emerging from piecing of yarn;
moreover, extra labor is required as an operative can only piece
a limited number of threads per unit time. The amount of waste
produced is proportional to the product of end breakage rate and
the average time an end is down.
If the RPM of a machine is increased without considering the
spinning conditions, the result will be retardation of the
spinning process; not only the expected production would be
unachievable but also the quality would deteriorate.
For example, if 5% increase in spindle RPM of the ring
spinning frame results in 4% increase of ends down and, in order
to control yarn breakages, 1% increase in twist is introduced,
the production will remain the same, but the yarn will give more
defects and unnecessary additional energy and materials would be
used/wasted. Therefore, without giving due weightage to over all
spinning conditions, an increase in machine speed means
deliberately inviting reduction in efficiency.
Current spinning technology is developed, with an aim to
maintain higher productivity, with effective quality control, by
selecting suitable equipment and spinning conditions to match
with the raw materials. Modern developments of machinery, labor
demands and increased market competition compel the spinner to
produce as satisfactory yarn as economically possible.
The problem of waste is well recognized, but nothing is done
except to collect it, either to sell or reprocess it. In recent
times waste has become a serious problem for the following
reasons:
1. Raw material and labor costs are rising resulting
in an increase of manufacturing cost.
2. Machinery investment today is much greater than
ever before.
3. External and internal competition at market level
is expanding, thus necessitating reduction of price and/or
improvement in efficiency in order to remain competitive.
It is a popular misconception that the cost of producing
waste is mainly a factor of raw material cost. The cost of waste
production may thus be severely under estimated, since these
factors must be considered in any assessment of the losses
involved.
1. Raw Material Cost.
2. Processing Cost
3. Handling Costs.
4. The reduction in machine efficiency and production
quality
5. Loss in selling profits.
6. Reprocessing cost (if any).
7. Sale value of the waste. (if the waste is sold)
8. Energy Cost.
Above factors show that the losses progressively increase
throughout the processing cycle. The cost per Kilogram of
producing waste in Ring being significantly higher than the cost
per Kilogram for the earlier processes. Thus, from cost point of
view more gains may be in the later processes. To save energy
(which is one of the main cost factors) it will be better to
reduce whorl dia of spindle to increase the RMP of the spindle
with the same power.
Causes of cotton waste
The production of the high quality yarn free from faults and
its production in bulk quantities are the major considerations
in spinning. Yarn breakages and their gradual increase with
spindle speed causes a problem.
As a result of frequent yarn breakages the waste percentage
will increase and the quality of the yarn breakages the waste
percentage will increase and the quality of the yarn is also
impaired by the thick places emerging from him piecing of the
end, thus the operative can only piece a limited number of
threads per unit time.
In other words the number of ends down is directly related to
waste. Thus the amount of waste produced is proportional to the
product of end breakage rate and the average time an end is
down. A large number of other variables which affect waste
production are raw material, room and fiber conditioning,
processing variables, operators and mechanical conditions
Raw material
The blending of different varieties of cotton is normally the
responsibility of the spinner. With natural fibers, such as
cotton, the maintenance of a completely uniform blend can be
very difficult indeed. The first concern of the spinner is to
control staple length and fiber fineness, so as to maintain
consistent spinning conditions and standard yarn properties.
His second concern is generally with yarn appearance in
particular color. He will do his best to ensure that when yarns
from different deliveries are compared, the weaver will not be
able to see any difference between them. For this proper mixing
schedule cross creeling and grading of raw material is a must,
according to the count spun from that material.
Room and
fiber conditioning
The natural fibers are highly sensitive to the conditions of
the ambient air; they are hydroscopic, so that the moisture
present, whether expressed as moisture content or re-gain
depends to temperature. The mechanical properties of fibers and
yarn depend upon the humidity and temperature.
Atmospheric conditions thus influence the rate at which
machine can be worked. In a very dry climate or atmosphere, the
electrical charges generated by friction, if not conducted away
makes it difficult to retain the control of the yarn. Correct
R.H.% ensures the working of yarn with minimum risk of breakage,
reduction of static electricity by reason of the greater
electrical conductivity of the yarn, the amount of fly liberated
is also reduced. Moisture content of the textile material
affects the physical behavior of the product.
So the conditioning of fiber plays a major part in spinning,
variation from optimum conditions can bring about a large
increase in the amount of waste produced. Under dry conditions
the generation of static electricity promotes the formation of
feather edge sliver, roving and yarn which often gets attached
to the revolving parts of the machine, too moist conditions also
give trouble.
The user of oil can be beneficial since it tends to reduce
static charges, can reduce the need for more accurate humidity
control and can affect the ends down. The addition of oil can
also reduce the amount of fly waste. The addition of anti-static
agents is very effective in reducing waste. Antistatic agents
allow lower relative humidities, since charges are neutralized
as soon as they are formed. However, when an antistatic agent is
present more oil can be tolerated.
Processing
variables
The treatment given during spinning and adjustment of the
various machines, exercise considerable influence upon the
quality of yarn spun. If the given mixing is not processed
property, some of the fibers may be damaged during their passage
through, various machines; this would not only increase the
waste percentage, but would also results in inferior quality of
products. The goods manufactured under such conditions would
increase the cost price and reduce the margin of profits.
Therefore, processing variables such as doubling, drafts, ratch
settings, twists, etc in turn effect the amount of waste
processing variables, such as doubling drafts, ratch settings;
twists, etc.
The conversion of lap to yarn results in the reduction of
weight per unit length of the input material, whilst maintaining
product uniformity. The uniformity is affected by the weight of
draft. High drafts above certain optimum limit produce more
irregularity. With the advent of high draft much more attention
has to be paid to accurate settings to maintain quality.
In practice, the reduction in weight per unit length is
carried out in stages, each drafting operation introduces fresh
irregularity, the irregularity of the final yarn being the
“summation” of irregularity produced by each operation. Doubling
is used as a method of improving the product uniformity, a
compromise having to be made between the benefits of extra
doubling and the detrimental effects of the extra drafting,
which doubling entails.
There is a limit to the number of doublings passage which
improves yarn levelness. During carding fiber become hooked and
the direction in which the hooked fiber are presented to each
process is important. Although later drafting processes tend to
reduce the hooks, they are never completely eliminated, the
higher the draft,the greater is the need to present the fibers
to the drafting system with their hooks trailing.
The direction of fibers is reversed at each packaging
operation and since most of the fibers leaving the card have
trailing hooks, there would be an even number of packaging
processes between the card and the ring frame, in other words
there should be an odd number of machines or processes.
When this is the case fibers enter the drafting system of the
ring frames, where the draft is normally the highest with their
hooks trailing. Failure to present the fibers in the appropriate
direction at the ring frame can result in a loss of strength of
upto 10%. In other words, ends down in Ring will increase,
therefore, it is advisable not to put sliver of one can to
another.
Fiber breakage is a function of two main factors, the ratch
setting and the roving twist. It is necessary to set the ratch
longer than the longest fiber to avoid breakages, since a short
ratch will break all fibers greater in length. For a given ratch
the extent of machine control over the fibers depends on the
length distribution, a wider distribution and longer rather
leading to less fiber control.
Twist is used to provide cohesion between the fibers, so as
to maintain control over the short fibers, however, this tends
to restrict fiber movement and increase in breakages. As the
attenuation is increased the amount of twist must be increased,
to maintain the strength required to withstand, winding on
tension and the tension of withdrawal from the creel at the next
operation. This increase in twist combined with the decrease in
the number of fibers per cross section must inevitably lead to
fiber breakage.
The strain and distortion imposed on fiber ends during
drafting due to the initial pull, continually repeated at each
operation on alternate ends of the fiber, must lead to an
increase in breakage. It is to be expected, therefore, that
fibers will be beheaded or betailed as a result of this stress
and fatigue, the effect being more important for longer fibers.
Yarns with high/ normal twist break at thicker spot, because
of poor twist propagation. Breakage is caused primarily by the
production of thin places but breakage tends to be caused by
fiber slipping rather than fiber breakages. High tenacity of
fiber causes more static charges in drafting.
Operator
The operator plays an important role in the production,
handling of material between processess, cleaning, collecting of
waste, etc. The consequences of poor operators and/or incorrect
operating procedures.
Excess waste produced by a particular operator, however, may
not be only his responsibility, but also that of the supervisor
and management. It is the responsibility of management to
arrange the staffing of the installation, the classification of
the work to be carried out by particular type of operators, the
setting out of detailed operating procedures and techniques and
the training schedules for supervisors and operators.
It is the responsibility of the supervisor to arrange the
operator training and to keep constant check that the operating
procedures are carried out correctly. Excess waste produced by
an operator may thus be a function of inefficient operating
procedures, inadequate training, poor supervision and lack of
skills in carrying out particular procedures and/or operator
carelessness.
An important operative effect on the amount of waste is the
spinner patrol cycles, the average time an end is down is
greater and thus more waste will be produced. If the end is down
too long a further loss may occur due to the building up of a
malformed package.
Mechanical condition
Machinery can be kept upto date only by using proper
maintenance schedule. The proper maintenance and updating of
machinery is also one of the most important factors to get
better quality and optimum production from machine.
In the blowroom, the machinery is mainly expected to open the
bales, blend the Cotton from various bales, clean the Cotton
from impurities and present it in the form of sheets made of
small tuft to the next process. The function of various machines
in spinning and their impact on yarn quality suggests, that the
processing parameters that are likely to have an impact on yarn
irregularity are production rate and settings in carding, and
hence these effect fiber separation and level of waste.
The drawframe is essentially meant to parallelize the fibers
and to reduce medium and long term irregularities present in the
sliver fed to fly and ring frame drafts. Therfore, any research
for cause of high yarn irregularity should, therefore, include
an assessment of the correctness of these parameters.
Furthermore, the importance of fiber control, brings out the
need for checking the aspects of fly and ring frame, break
draft, spacer and setting between rollers. It is not possible to
set universally applicable norms for all the parameters
enumerated above. However, inter mill comparison and studies
provide broad guide lines.
Roll drafting, or the attenuation of slivers and roving to
produce yarn of specified counts, is perhaps the most important
principle involved in the processing of raw cotton into yarn.
The more nearly perfect the drafting at each yarn preparation
machine, the stronger and more uniform will be the spun yarn.
It is important, therefore, that the drafting at each process
and especially in the spinning of the yarn should be as perfect
as possible, but in practical an ideal condition of drafting can
never be attained at any process or in any machine. This is true
because of the varied factors that effect drafting, some of the
more important of which are:
1. The accuracy and suitability of roll settings.
2. The employment of reasonable roll speeds.
3. Correct weighting of rolls.
4. The amount of draft.
5. The condition of the drawing rolls.
6. The physical characteristics of the cotton fiber.
With the advent of high drafting much more attention has to
be paid to accurate setting to maintain quality. High draft
requires perfectly fluted rolls with a minimum of run out;
quality yarn depends on quality rolls. Spinning spindle speeds
have in recent times reached or surpassed the 15,000 rpm. This
calls for a more precise centering of the spindle, than was the
practice when 9,000 rpm was considered a high speed. Imperfect
centering will have a considerable effect on yarn quality,
including yarn fuzziness, increased end breakage, premature and
irregular ring wear and rapid traveler deterioration. This
causes the length of yarn between the traveler and the winding
point to vary. If we consider that the traveler lies on a normal
plane at the yarn delivery and the difference in yarn length
must come from the winding point.
Only that the travelers is being dragged and not driven, plus
yarn elasticity keeps the yarn from breaking. As the travelers
is being dragged, it is free to follow the movements imposed by
the yarn and will varies its speed.
The difference in winding points is recovered by yarn, which
is already wound and the traveler is forced to suddenly,
accelerate and decelerate at its opposite points. Two negative
effects are traveler behavior and the effects on yarn quality,
the traveler in normal working conditions varies its speed and
position according to the slow variation of the winding
diameter. However, when spindle is eccentric, the condition
created by the eccentric spindle forces sudden speed variations.
The deceleration creates an inertia movement and a consequent
in yarn tension. This forces the traveler to change its normal
inclination and to assume almost vertical position. A sudden
acceleration causes the traveler to learn excessively and to
come into contact with both the upper and lower part of the
ring.
This condition results in aggravated ring wear, as the
traveler is creating heavy friction by working in wedged
position. Thread tension is consequently increased. If the
mechanical damage resulting from the above situation is
considerable, than the yarn quality will obviously suffer. A
bobbin of yarn spun of this spindle will be quite fuzzy, with
the degree of fuzziness relating directly to the spindle
eccentricity, so proper maintenance is one of the most important
factors to get quality and production from the machine.
Waste control
It is important to examine the problem of waste control in
terms of all processes rather than just the problems involved in
Ring. Since saving in one department may lead to increased waste
in other departments.
It is clear for example that significant improvement may be
expected by placing more emphasis on a more uniform initial
product. It is also important to think in terms of subsequent
processing after spinning i.e. weaving, finishing etc. since any
economy in spinning which results is low yarn quality may have
adverse effects in later processes.
The control of waste may be carried out by taking steps to
obtain optimum processing conditions and by implementing a waste
control scheme.
Given a particular raw material and particular mill there
must be an optimum set of conditions, i.e. relative humidity,
doubling, draft, machine settings etc. which will give the best
quality in conjunction with minimum waste. No two mills are
alike, i.e. the optimum conditions in one mill may not be the
optimum in another. In order to obtain the best results, it is
necessary to carry out a continuing experimental programme
constantly varying roller settings, spindle speeds, traveler
weight, etc. until the best combination is achieved for each
count and quality. Careful recording of the results is necessary
and the sampling methods used must stand up to statistical
demands.
After obtaining the best technical standards, the next step
is to put these standards into practice. It is also necessary to
record the performance of each lot as a guide to future
experimentation, so that standards may be constantly revised to
maintain optimum conditions.
An important feature in the maintenance of technical
standards is the institution of continuous and systematic
quality control and preventive maintenance, when these later
processes are adequately maintained, the likelihood of
significant waste due to machine faults is greatly reduced.
It should be realized in all spinning room testing that only
very small percentage of spindles are tested, so that constant
visual checks and periodic re settings are necessary to ensure
that these are representative of the whole.
The implementation of regular end break checks can be
invaluable, as an aid in the maintenance of end break rates to
predetermined levels end, in the location of faulty spindles. It
is good practice to number every spindle on every frame and to
note the spindle on which end break occur during the checks, so
that spindle with high end break rates may be detected.
Control scheme
It is important to note that a “Waste drive” will be
virtually useless, unless it is followed up by systematic
methods and supervision. It is often not good enough to call in
supervisors to announce that departments are producing too much
waste and that they had better do some thing about it.
As a first step the problem should be explained intelligently
in terms of cost, quality and job security to all key
supervisors and their cooperation to run the scheme would be
advisable so that various aspects may be adequately coordinated.
The next step is to determine the location of waste problem.
This will usually involve the combined thinking of supervisors
and management and this can be arranged by organizing a series
of periodic meetings on waste to be attended by all concerned
individuals. Each supervisor should be encouraged to talk about
his particular waste problem and suggest methods of reducing the
waste.
Last, but not the least, it is essential in any waste control
programme, that a scheme of classification and sorting of waste
is designed and implemented.
|