|
1. Quality concept
1.1. Introduction
What does quality mean?
What has quality got to do with commercial success?
There are many definitions of quality and also many opinions.
No definition will therefore be given at this point. It is simpler
to say what 50% or 80% or 98% quality means. For example, 98%
quality is equivalent to1:
· no running water for 7 days a year
· 30 mins. without power per day
· or monthly wages are not paid to 1.2 million German
employees because it was forgotten to transfer the money.
The PMIS1 studies state that quality, market shares and the
ROI (Return on Investment) have a strong positive correlation2
.
· Quality results in increase of market share
· Quality produces better prices in the market
· Quality can compensate for a lower market share
· Quality and high market share have an above-average
influence on profits3
It is well known that process reliability and reproducibility
promote product quality. But quality is also a product feature,
which our customers demand and cannot be copied by our competitors.
Lack of quality causes quality costs:
We alone are responsible for quality costs. No competitor,
no customer and no high personnel costs can be blamed for them.
If we reduce these quality costs, we can practically credit
this to our earnings side as profit. Quality is the guarantee
of commercial success. The following statement thereby gains
validity:
"The machine constructor can make a contribution to the
commercial success of the textile finisher by increasing quality,
reproducibility and process reliability."
1.2. Quality concept over the course of time
The concept of quality has changed considerably during the
past 50 years. In the 50s and 60s quality was equated with technical
perfection. "Made in Germany" was synonymous throughout
the world for a high quality standard. Products were faultless
and distinguished by their high technical standard. Quality
was exclusively a technical parameter. Those who have jumped
the bar at the highest level are the winners.
In the 1970s "Made in Japan" initiated a new wave
of quality consciousness. It started with the Japanese photographic
industry, followed by hi-fi and the motor trade. Cheaper mass-produced
articles, which can often be replaced, corresponded to a higher
living standard. Long life was no longer in demand. Quality
was also no longer measurable, since customers had their own
interpretation.
Quality is in the eye of the beholder.
Then in the 1980s came the euphoria for mass produced articles
and the bar height for quality was clearly defined. This produced
products of relatively high quality at an acceptable price.
Quality was exactly defined. The bar for the high jumper is
exactly defined. The aim is to jump over the bar - no more and
no less. Quality was therefore no longer something absolute,
but something exactly defined.
A brake was put on the hunt for length and height.
During the 1990s technology matured to such perfectionism that
no further limits were set to technical quality. The quality
technically possible lies above the quality required. People
suddenly turned out to be one of the weak links in the value
added chain. They were no longer able to follow the technology.
From the last 50 years quality policy therefore emerged the
2000+ quality concept, which is defined as follows: Quality
is achieved when the provision of performance is economical,
ecological, socially balanced and lasting.
2. Points of reference for optimizing quality in textile
finishing processes
2.1 Causes of quality deficiencies
From the cause-effect diagram according to K. Ishikawa4 (best
known Japanese quality expert) the 4 causes machines/fixtures,
people, methods and material are decisive.
Machine/fixture: Deviations in quality can be of a mechanical
nature, but can also occur owing to insufficient maintenance,
since the machine has a high proportion of wearing components
(the essence of wearing parts is considered again separately
later). A significant loss of quality, however, is also too
low productivity or inadequate washing result. Both are faults
in the specification of the system, since the expectations of
the textile finisher are not satisfied.
Method: The production sequences selected, composition formulae,
etc. do not comply with the anticipated quality. With desizing
for example, this can be caused by the selected method not being
suitable for all size types. Since, however, the size also changes
with changing raw material and the desizing bath is not normally
changed continually, a multi-functional desizing bath is required
for as many size mixtures as possible.
People: While formerly all textile finishing processes could
be influenced by manipulations of the operator and these manipulations
were also necessary, the result was largely in the hands of
the operator. While formerly the quality of the machine construction
held pride of place, today the control of the process and assurance
of the result assume most importance, regardless of personnel
and geographic influencing parameters.
Material: A comprehensive quality policy also calls for inclusion
of the supplier in the added value chain. Unfortunately it is
not possible for the textile industry in central Europe for
geographical reasons to bind the cotton manufacturers closer.
It is well known that the imported raw materials are subject
to wide fluctuations. This situation is further deteriorating
for commission finishers, since the origin of the cotton is
entirely unknown. For manmade fibre materials it has already
been possible to involve the suppliers. These are in particular
technical fibres such as PA 6.6 for airbags as well as Lyocell
and Tencel for the fashion clothing trade. The fibre manufacturers
are available to offer advice here to the finisher.
2.2 Contribution to improving the quality within an investment
cycle
Based on the cause/effect diagram the machine constructor can
make a contribution at various times to quality and process
reliability within the life cycle of a textile finishing machine
(figure 2).
Phase 1: Investment requirement/new procurement (textile finisher)
- sales process (machine constructor)
Normally the opinion of the marketing or distribution employee
is that they have scarcely anything to do with quality, since
this subject belongs rather to manufacturing or quality assurance5
. This has for a long time been a mistake of the machine manufacturer.
The satisfaction of consumer and customer wishes is required
in order to meet the expectations of the textile finisher. In
practice this corresponds to the preparation of a specification.
In these phases the relevant dimensions and guidelines are also
prepared, which are later consulted for evaluation of the result.
Phase 2: Determination of preparation/ methods (textile finisher)
- production, installation, commissioning (machine constructor)
Phase 2 serves more or less as a transition for the textile
finisher. For the machine constructor this is the most important
phase. He has to implement the criteria determined in phase
1 in the machine construction.
The new textile finishing machine is produced, installed and
put into service. The textile finisher can make suitable preparations
in this phase. He can prepare methods and compositions, as well
as train the future operating personnel.
Phase 3: Use (textile finisher) - customer service, spare-parts
service (machine constructor)
For the textile finisher the phase then begins for redemption
of the investment made. High quality leads to greater commercial
success, e.g. the PIMS studies show that high quality leads
to increase of market share and also to the prices set in the
market. In other words, there is a positive correlation between
quality and market share.
The textile finisher must ensure that a uniform and constant
product quality is achieved. The foundation stone for this was
laid in phase 1. The product concept of the machine constructor
must be matched to the demand. If deviations nevertheless occur,
these must be resolved within the scope of the so-called exceptional
case. The customer service can make a contribution here either
by direct telephone line or by a telephone-modem connection
to control the system for elimination of the fault as quickly
as possible. The utilization phase of a textile finishing system
still usually lasts over 10 years in Europe. Preventive maintenance
avoids the occurrence of undesirable faults and deviations.
The spareparts service of the machine constructor helps to keep
the machine in the original condition all the time.
Phase 4: Investment requirement, new procurement
The best product concept and the best maintenance do not help
and innovation in machine construction and process development
result in the quality of the existing (old) machine one day
no longer being state-of-the-art. This can either be the technical
quality or also lower production costs in a modern system. The
modern concept of quality always places quality in conjunction
with the price. (Juran 6:What brings me quality? What costs
me quality?7). A substitute investment must therefore improve
both the actual product quality as well as the production costs.
2.3 Extract from possible quality programs
Examples will now be given below of quality-promoting measures
in textile machine construction. The following quality programs
are presented in detail:
· Quality management in marketing
· Quality management in development and design with examples
· Avoidance of potential sources of danger
· Incorporation of freedom from maintenance
· Quality management in production based on the following
examples
· Continuous monitoring of reference and actual values
and continuous correction
· Automation of sequences possible to influence
· "Speak with data"8
· Regulation of exceptional status based on example
3. Examples
3.1 Quality management in marketing:
Marketing is the primary interface between the company and the
market, while at the same time also being the start to a possible
commercial success. The machine constructor is confronted with
the daily questions:
What does the market demand?
What does the textile finisher demand for his own best solution?
The marketing department is answerable for the first question.
Continuous market analysis and market research are indispensable
for revealing trends. This article does not consider the various
market research tools in detail and looks only at the 2nd question.
The textile machine constructor must successfully produce the
best combination of modules from his production program in order
to offer an individual solution for the textile finisher. The
objective must be to find the optimum solution to satisfy the
individual requirements of the textile finisher from familiar
and proven elements. Only proven elements can eliminate weak
points, which otherwise cause quality breakdowns. This does
not mean that new developments are of poor quality, but rather
that new developments must be composed of familiar elements.
In the formulation of the quality concept 2000+ It was stated
that quality is also something durable and continuity is called
for.
Following takeover of the wet finishing division of the company
KTM/Krefeld, Benninger today has a full range of wet finishing
plants for open width treatment of woven and knitted fabrics.The
product range of Benninger has therefore been supplemented in
washing and bleaching with the machine program for knitted goods.
In the dyeing sector (BEN-COLOUR) with the BICOFLEX padding
machine the last product gap has now also been closed in continuous
and semi-continuous dyeing. In order to provide the customer
with the complete infrastructure, Benninger now has a powder
dissolving station developed by itself and fluid chemicals station
in the production program. All machine modules can be combined
without interfaces. In addition to the machine elements Benninger
also supplies the process and drive control units.
3.2 Quality management in K&E:
"Avoidance of potential sources of danger" - wear
of roller rubber when washing off textiles with high chemical
loading. Two questions must be answered for potential sources
of danger:
1st question: Do I really need this part?
2nd question: Must I adapt this part to the operating conditions
or can the conditions be improved for the critical part?
Rubberized rollers are critical components in the textile finishing
industry and also represent a potential source of danger. Large
amounts of chemicals and high temperature lead to rapid and
uncontrollable wear.
Following an impregnation and reaction process, residual chemicals,
fibre- accompanying materials and converted reaction products
must be washed out. Many reaction processes run in a steam atmosphere.
In addition to rapid reaction kinetics, the accompanying materials
such as oil and grease are also converted to a low viscosity
form. A cooling of the cloth at this point during washing would
return grease and oils to the original high viscosity form.
It is known that the washing efficiency in hot water is likewise
substantially higher than in cold water. Washing processes immediately
following steaming processes therefore represent unfavourable
conditions for rubber rollers. Cold washing would improve the
operating conditions, but worsen the textile result. In other
words, the critical part (here the first washing section following
a reaction process) must be adapted to the environmental conditions.
This is most simply achieved by avoiding rubber rollers at such
places.
The FORTRACTA washing compartment from Benninger Uzwil AG has
been specially developed for removing surface soiling and high
chemical loads. The textile web is taken upwards in 2 shafts.
The washing liquor runs down like a waterfall under gravity.
A high washing effect is achieved by means of this counterflow
principle in the shaft. The liquor separation is achieved by
stripping rollers and flat jet nozzles at the outlet of the
compartment.
The FORTRACTA washing compartment consists of a stainless steel
design with 2 washing chambers. There are two narrow shafts
between the 2 washing chambers. The design is such that the
washing compartment is only provided with smooth surfaces and
is therefore self-cleaning. There is no need for rubber rollers
as drawing or liquor separating elements. Chemical loads are
practically halved in a FORTRACTA prewashing assembly. This
corresponds to the washing effect of a conventional high capacity
washing compartment with 30 m fabric content. This high efficiency
can only be used once, however, to remove chemicals and contamination
adhering to the surface. The dilution wash can then be continued
without problem in conventional roller vats with the prewashed
cloth. Since the chemicals and dirt have already been considerably
reduced, rubber rollers can be used again. With the FORTRACTA
prewashing compartment Benninger has created a unit which complies
with the quality objectives "avoidance of danger sources"
and "quality at acceptable costs (fitness for use)".
3.3 "Incorporation of freedom from maintenance"- TPM
Total Productive Maintenance
The expression "incorporation of freedom from maintenance"
originates from TPM (Total Productive Maintenance), which was
already introduced in Japan in the mid-70s.9
It is often not the actual maintenance which is the problem,
but rather the time for maintenance that is decisive. The characteristic
of wearing parts is that they attain their highest quality following
a brief introductory phase. They then decline increasingly in
performance with increasing wear and the textile result changes
slowly until final quality failure.
There is no place for wearing parts in modern textile machines,
which have a direct influence on the textile results. It was
long customary to use transmission drives in textile finishing
plant construction. Chains, belts and mechanical sliding clutches
were used. These are all wearing parts, which cannot guarantee
reproducibility of textile results with regard to cloth transport,
freedom from creasing and fabric extension.
Benninger has replaced all transmission drives by individual
roller drives. In the vertical washing vats all top rollers
can be fitted with a.c. motors In the pretreatment and dyeing
steamers, as well as the hotflue and thermosol drying chambers,
the drive components can be selected according to cloth weight
and demand. In the TRIKOFLEX drum washing machine the drum drives
are likewise fitted with wear-free a.c. drives. A.C. drives
are practically wear-free and require very little maintenance.
They therefore ensure a reproducible and creaseless cloth transport.
3.4 Automatic metering of chemicals using inductive flowmeters
for impregnation processes as exemplified by the IMPACTA high-moisture
application assembly:
Hardware and software solutions, which satisfy automatic control
and regulation functions, are assigned to the category of quality
management in production. With metering of chemicals it is a
matter of satisfying the following quality criteria:
· Continuous MONITORING and comparison of reference
and actual values in order to obtain reproducibility throughout
the period of use.
· Provision of back-up solution for exceptional circumstances.
· Elimination of manipulation possibilities by an expert
system
A chemicals station consists for each chemical of a feed pump,
an inductive flowmeter and a control valve (figure 4).
The concentrated chemicals are fed into the circulating pipe
of the IMPACTA to ensure good mixing. The reference value is
calculated according to the recipe entered (ml chemical per
kg cloth) depending on the cloth throughput, determined from
square metre weight multiplied by the width and the speed.
An exactly defined volume of chemicals is added by metering
in ml/kg corresponding to the cloth throughput. Inductive flowmeters
measure the ACTUAL flow and compare this with the REFERENCE.
If a deviation from the REFERENCE and ACTUAL values occurs,
an automatic dynamic correction of the flow volume is made.
The impregnating system is self-regulating. Water is added depending
on the level. If more water is added with the cloth, the amount
of water added dependent on level is reduced automatically.
The metering system operates in the regulating range 1:100.
If minimum volumes are required, the metering system changes
over automatically to clock cycles.
The IMPACTA is a high moisture application system for wet on
wet impregnation and is mainly used for preliminary treatment.
A major advantage of this unit is that a liquor exchange takes
place in the bath. In other words, the water added is exchanged
for chemicals. Not all articles have the same liquor exchange
rate and the same liquor uptake. The bath concentration in ml/l,
however, is largely influenced by these two parameters. If articles
with different characteristic are produced in succession without
production stoppage, it is necessary to change the bath concentration
in ml/l online. All Benninger systems are fitted with a "programmable
logic control" (PLC).
This makes it possible to automate processes of this kind.
As can be seen from formula 1 for the calculation of the liquor
concentration, the bath concentration is calculated from the
feed liquor concentration in ml/kg (the actual recipe) and the
liquor pick-up inlet and outlet and the exchange factor. Computation
from the liquor pick-up and the exchange factor is called "effective
pick-up". It can be seen from formula 2 that the bath concentration
changes by variation of the "effective pick-up" with
the same feed liquor concentration. If therefore the "effective
pick-up" changes, a change of bath concentration is necessary.
Formula 1:
Feed liquor conc. (ml/kg) Liquor pick-up inlet x liquor
exchange +
(Liquor pick-up outlet - liquor pick-up inlet)
Formula 2:
Feed liquor conc. (ml/kg)
Effective pick-up
Benninger has created an expert system, in which over 2000 individual
tests on a wide variety of articles, speeds, temperatures, etc.
play a part. By definition of the article the relevant effective
pick-up is automatically assigned to the composition formula
via the data archiving program and the initial concentration
and the necessary volume of chemicals calculated in litres.
In the case of a first filling this is very simple, since the
volume of the IMPACTA is known and stored in the PLC. Alteration
of the concentration during an article change is also possible
without stoppage. By changing the "effective pick-up"
or by loading a new composition formula, the control unit recognizes
that this results in a change of liquor concentration. The user
can maintain a dialogue with the control unit by means of a
touch-screen and is asked whether a change of bath concentration
is required. The change of concentration is then started by
being acknowledged. Even the acknowledgement operation could
be automated. For this purpose a max. tolerance limit for e.g.
2% deviation from the original bath concentration must be specified.
If the tolerance limit is exceeded when changing the article,
the change in concentration takes place automatically.
The change in concentration takes place in such a way that
the bath must either be strengthened with chemicals ("effective
pick-up new" less than "effective pick-up old")
or it must be diluted (effective pick-up new" greater than
"effective pick-up old").
In the first case the necessary volume of chemicals is automatically
added within seconds to the existing bath. In the second case
water is added for dilution.
Metering of feed liquor in ml/kg is not affected in either
case and is continued.
The metering system described complies with the requirements
of quality management with regard to REFERENCE-ACTUAL comparison
and control, as well as regulation of the exception status as
exemplified by change of concentration.
3.5 Regulation and control of liquor pick-up in impregnating
systems for specific articles
The following quality criteria must be satisfied:
· Reproducible liquor pick-up
· Provision of a monitoring tool (Speak with Data)
· Control of exception status
The contribution by Benninger Uzwil AG to the assurance of
an article-specific and controllable liquor pick-up should be
mentioned again on the IMPACTA high-moisture impregnating unit.
This example can be used in the same way, however, for all impregnating
processes and for the BICOFLEX padding machine.
A special 2 roller squeezing unit ensures a controlled and
speed-independent liquor pick-up. Previously 2 roller squeezers
were unsuitable with regard to controllability in the high moisture
range. Benninger has modified the design so that the dead weight
of the squeezing roller has no influence on the liquor pick-up,
since the centre of gravity of the squeezing roller lies directly
above the pivot point of the squeezing mechanism. The pneumatic
system has been designed so that the smallest pressures can
be set exactly.
Owing to the low pressure there is a danger that the squeezing
roller nip would spring open when passing seams or other thick
places. This condition is termed an exceptional status in quality
management.
Independent closing is not possible owing to the minimum nip
pressure. Benninger has positioned a sensor to monitor the nip
joint, which continuously measures the distance of the two rollers.
If an opening of the squeezer takes place for the reasons mentioned
above, this is immediately detected and a special nip closing
algorithm is activated. The squeezer is returned to its original
position within 2 seconds and the bleaching liquor is supplied
in its customary uniform and reproducible volume.
Benninger places emphasis on the application of high moisture
on the fabric web suitable for the specific article. A maximum
application would often exceed the liquor bearing capacity of
the treated fabric.
Liquor losses occur following the addition of steam condensate
in the bleaching steamer, which lead to non-reproducible results
and loss of chemicals by precipitation.10
Benninger also has a system for measuring the liquor addition
and approximate representation of the total liquor pick-up.
Edwards Deming, a quality expert from the USA, advocates the
idea.
"Speak with data"
Deming states that facts and data play an important role for
decisions on the evaluation of quality or lack of quality. He
criticizes decisions reached on the basis of intuition and sixth
sense. 11
This formulation is particularly useful in the textile finishing
industry marked by tradition. The relative figure liquor pick-up
is familiar to experts and is a value with which it can be assessed
blind whether a parameter corresponds or not.
Modern textile finishing systems have a lot of information
thanks to the PLC controller, which are only bits and bytes
to software people and have no significance. This is also true
of the information obtained from the inductive flowmeters. The
software for a metering system calculates the metered volume
in ml/min. from the cloth throughput and the composition formula.
It was forgotten that all information is present in the PLC
controller for the calculation of a resulting liquor pick-up.
The sum of all infeeds to an impregnating system is obtained
from the inductive flowmeters. When computed, this gives the
total supply per minute to the impregnating system. The quotient
of liquid volume supplied and cloth throughput gives the value
of liquor addition (the density of the bleach liquor is ignored
here). The sum from the addition and the inlet moisture, which
is obtained quite reliably from the Benninger experts system,
gives the approximate total liquor pick-up.
A proportional figure can be created here by means of a simple
mathematical algorithm to serve as an important monitoring aid
for every textile specialist. It is not a matter here of attaching
an additional sensor system to the machine, but of processing
information from existing regulating and control tools required
for other purposes, in such a way that it is useful for the
user. This is possible by the addition of all inputs to an impregnating
compartment and a simple mathematical operation. The machine
operator has a control instrument here, which provides him with
continuous information about an important proportional figure
and can result in early fault detection. The average liquor
pick-up can also be recorded on the production report, printed
out and used for quality assurance. The positive factor for
the machine purchaser is that the investment amount is only
insignificantly increased by additional software (the hardware
is necessary in any case).
4. Summary
Quality and commercial success are closely related. The
machine constructor has various points of reference for a positive
influence on the quality of the result by the textile finisher.
Quality management begins with marketing, continues with design
and development and the quality must then be demonstrated in
daily use, i.e. during production by the textile finisher. The
essential features of quality policy in the construction of
textile finishing systems are avoidance of potential sources
of danger, incorporation of freedom from maintenance, monitoring
of reference and actual values and handling of the exception
status. All these are measures for increasing process safety
and reproducibility. Quality leads to confidence of customers
and establishment of a close customer bond. Therefore for the
textile finisher and machine constructor:
QUALITY is achieved when the customer returns and not the product
5. Literature and source index
Backhaus Klaus: Industriegütermarketing, 5th edition,
Munich 1997, Benninger, BEN-BLEACH, brochure, Flawil 1999
Hauser Bondo: Qualitätsmanagement in der Textilindustrie,
in Textilveredlung 5/6 1998, Zürich 1998
Hopfenbeck Waldemar: Allgemeine Betriebswirtschafts- und Manage-mentlehre,
4th edition, Landsberg am Lech, 1991
Kotler Philip: Marketing- Management, 9the edition, Bliemel
Friedhelm Stuttgart 1999
Oess Attila: Total Quality Management, Die ganzheitliche Qualitätsstrategie,
3rd edition, Wiesbaden 1993.
|